Your Hebrew birthday after sunset
One civil date can hold two Hebrew dates. Understanding the evening boundary makes a birthday conversion more honest and more useful.

The day turns in the evening
A Jewish calendar date begins in the evening rather than at midnight. Someone born after nightfall belongs to the next Hebrew date compared with someone born earlier on the same civil date. This can change the day of the month and, at a month boundary, the month itself.
A birth record gives a civil date, but that date alone does not always answer the Hebrew-calendar question. The time in relation to the evening boundary is part of the information you need.
Make room for uncertainty
Sunset and nightfall are not the same moment. The twilight between them, traditionally called bein hashmashot, is a period of uncertainty. A recollection such as “around sunset” should not be converted into a precision the recollection does not contain.
If the time is unknown or near this boundary, keep both candidate dates. Ask relatives, check an original record if one exists, and be willing to leave the question open. Exploring two possibilities is often more useful than choosing one without evidence.
What the converter is doing
Mazalogy asks you to select before sunset, after nightfall, or unsure. The after-evening option advances the civil day before conversion; unsure shows both candidates. This is an explicit convention, not a calculation of historical local sunset.
For personal reflection, both dates can offer questions to explore. For a religious observance that depends on an uncertain birth time, bring the details to your community or rabbinic authority. The calendar result and the appropriate observance are related questions with different requirements.